| |
GROUP
RRSPs |
DEFINED
CONTRIBUTION PLAN |
GROUP
RRSPs |
| |
|
|
|
| Employee
Advantages |
- Usually
based on years of service and salary
- Guaranteed pension income
- Employer covers administrative costs and investment risk
- Creditor proof
|
- More flexible
than a defined benefit plan
- Creditor proof |
- Often many
investment choices
- Flexibility in retirement and estate planning |
|
Employer
Advantages |
- Makes older
workers easily to let go |
- Simpler
and less costly than DB plans
- Employees bear investment risk |
- No pension
standards required |
|
Contributions |
- Based on
actuarial calculations: age, gender, life expectancy, earnings growth
- Sometimes fully paid by employer
- Possible employee contribution option |
- Required
by employer
- Often a fixed contribution rate |
- Deducted
from pay, within regular RRSP limits
- Only employees may contribute; some employers raise pay and compel participation |
|
Tax Implications |
- Usually
employer alone contributes
- If employee contributes, deductible up to amount outlined in plan text |
- Employee
contributions deductible up to a yearly maximum of $13,500 |
- Employer
contributions are taxable and subject to CPP/QPP and EI |
|
Vesting |
- Generally
100% two years after joining the plan |
- Generally
100% two years after joining the plan |
- Vest immediately |
|
Portability |
- Awkward
when switching
- Three choices: leave "as is" and collect benefits at retirement,
transfer to new employer, open LIRA |
- Simpler
to move than DBs
- Usually same as for DB but value more transparent |
- Easily
transferable to another RRSP or employer plan |
|
Withdrawals |
- At retirement
only |
- At retirement
only |
- Permitted
but discouraged before retirement, firms may suspend contributions |
|
At Retirement |
- Monthly
pension check or life annuity often based on last five years' earnings
- Maximum $1,722.22 per year of service; eg. $60,277 for 35 years |
- No guarantees;
pension depends on investments
- Convert to either an annuity, locked in RRSP or Life Income Fund (LIF) |
- Payout
depends on contributions and investments
- Cash or transfer to another registered plan |
|
Cautions |
- Watch assumptions
on annual statement
- Might be intergrated with CPP/QPP benefits
- May not be adjusted for inflation
- Limits RRSP contribution room
|
- Do your
home work and study investment choices carefully |
- Ask for
propectuses and portfolio expenses |
|
Government
Regulations |
- Provincial
and federal pension legislation
- Income tax act |
- Provincial
and federal pension legislation
- Income tax act |
- Not subject
to pension laws |